G GRMCalculator.com
Menu

Appraisal for Rental Property: What the Appraiser Checks on an Income Property

An appraisal for rental property leans on leases, a rent roll and the rent schedule. See which forms a lender uses and where the rent multiplier shows up.

By the GRMCalculator.com team

An appraisal for rental property measures what the building earns as well as what it would sell for, so the appraiser asks for leases, a rent roll and an expense history on top of the usual inspection. On a one to four unit rental, that work goes on a different form than a house appraisal, and it comes back with a rent schedule attached.

Apartment building with yellow and grey siding and balconies, a multi-unit rental property valued in a rental property appraisal
A multi-unit apartment building with balconies and yellow and grey panels under a blue sky. Photo: Mia Vargas, Pexels License, via Pexels
Two-story duplex with two front doors, a small rental property type covered in a rental property appraisal
A two-story duplex with two front doors under one porch, the kind of small rental an appraiser values using its rents. Photo: Nashdean, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The market value of a rental property still comes from the three standard approaches. Rent simply carries more weight. For the one-step income math behind it, start with how to value a rental with gross rent multiplier. This guide covers what that overview leaves out: what the appraiser collects from you, which forms a lender orders, and what happens when the number lands under the contract price.

How a rental property appraisal differs from a house appraisal

An owner-occupied house is valued almost entirely on comparable sales. The appraiser finds three to six sold homes nearby, adjusts for size and condition, and reconciles to a figure. Rent never enters the report.

A rental adds an income layer. The appraiser has to document what the property collects, what similar units rent for, and whether the leases in place are at market. A real estate appraisal on an income property follows the same rules as any other, set out in the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice published by The Appraisal Foundation. The evidence file is just bigger.

The forms differ too. A single-family rental is usually appraised on the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report, Fannie Mae Form 1004, with a Single-Family Comparable Rent Schedule, Form 1007, added. Two to four units go on the Small Residential Income Property Appraisal Report, Form 1025, which has a rent grid built into it, often with an Operating Income Statement, Form 216. Five units or more leaves the form world and gets a narrative appraisal where income leads.

What the appraiser asks you for: leases, rent roll and expenses

Have this ready before the inspection. Missing paperwork is the most common reason an income appraisal stalls.

Lease agreement and two pens on a wooden desk, paperwork for an appraisal for rental property
A lease agreement and two pens on a wooden desk. Photo: RDNE Stock project, Pexels License, via Pexels
  • Signed leases for every unit, with start and end dates
  • A rent roll showing what each unit pays now, not asking rent
  • Two years of operating expenses: taxes, insurance, utilities, repairs, management
  • Who pays which utilities, in writing if the leases are vague
  • HOA or condo dues, if there are any
  • Vacancy and turnover history for the last year or two
  • A list of capital work done, with dates and costs
  • Interior access to every unit, which means giving tenants notice

Rent that is not in a lease does not count for much. Side agreements, cash rent and loose month to month arrangements get discounted or excluded, because the appraiser has to support every figure for a lender.

The three approaches applied to an income property

Every appraisal weighs three methods, then explains which one carried the conclusion.

The sales comparison approach prices the property against similar buildings that sold. On a duplex or fourplex this is usually the primary approach, with rent used to explain the differences between one comp and the next.

The income approach converts rent into value. On small residential property that often means a gross rent multiplier drawn from the same comparable sales. On larger buildings it means net operating income and a capitalization rate.

The cost approach estimates land value plus the cost to rebuild, less depreciation. It rarely drives the number on an older rental, but it shows up for new construction and for odd properties with no usable comps.

The appraiser then reconciles the three. A reconciled figure is an opinion of market value, not an average.

Where the rent multiplier shows up in the report

On small income property, the gross rent multiplier sits in a grid under the comparable sales. Each comp’s sale price is divided by its gross rent at the time of sale, a multiplier is chosen for the subject, and that multiplier is applied to the subject’s rent.

Take the standard example on this site. A $500,000 rental renting for $4,000 a month collects $48,000 a year, so its gross rent multiplier is about 10.4. If you only have an annual figure, the simple version works the same way: $500,000 on $50,000 of annual rent is a GRM of 10.

Run it backwards to see what the appraiser is doing. If the comps support a multiplier of 10 and the subject collects $48,000, the income indication is $480,000. That is $20,000 under a $500,000 contract price, and a gap like that is something the report has to address.

Monthly multipliers appear too, mostly on commercial forms. A GRM of 10.4 on annual rent is 125 on monthly rent, because $500,000 divided by $4,000 is 125. Check which one a report uses before comparing it to anything.

Reading the rent schedule attached to the appraisal

The rent schedule is a short comparison of three rented units near the subject, adjusted for bedroom count, size, condition and whether utilities are included. It concludes a market rent for each unit, and the lender uses that figure, not your lease, when it counts rental income toward the loan.

Four things to check. Are the rent comps in the same submarket? Do they match the unit mix? Are the leases quoted recent ones? Did the appraiser note in-place rent as below market, which is common on long-held buildings? The guide on the comparable rent schedule walks through that form line by line.

What to do when the appraised value comes in low

Start with facts, not opinion. Lenders accept a reconsideration of value, and the requests that work point at errors: a wrong unit count, a renovation the report missed, rent left off the rent roll, a comp that sold with a below-market lease in place.

Then supply sales the appraiser did not use, with addresses, dates and rents. Three strong comps beat ten weak ones.

If the value holds, the options are the usual ones. Renegotiate the price, bring more cash so the loan-to-value stays where the lender needs it, or walk. A fresh appraisal generally means a new application with another lender, and the first number does not vanish.

Sellers can head this off. Price from the market multiplier before listing, and the appraisal has a range to land in.

Check the multiplier before the appraisal lands

Enter a price and a rent in the GRM Calculator on the home page and you get the multiplier the property implies, plus the price any target multiplier supports. Compare that with what the comps show and a low appraisal stops being a surprise.

Frequently asked questions

What does an appraiser look at on a rental property?

The condition and layout of every unit, the lot and location, and then the income file: signed leases, a rent roll of what each unit pays now, two years of operating expenses, utility arrangements, vacancy history and capital work. The appraiser also pulls comparable sales and comparable rents, because a lender needs both the sale value and a supported market rent.

Which form is used for a rental property appraisal?

A single-family rental is usually appraised on the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report, Fannie Mae Form 1004, with a Single-Family Comparable Rent Schedule, Form 1007, attached. Two to four unit property goes on the Small Residential Income Property Appraisal Report, Form 1025, often with an Operating Income Statement, Form 216. Five units or more gets a narrative commercial appraisal with no standard form.

What is GRM in an appraisal?

The gross rent multiplier is price divided by gross rent. In an appraisal of small income property it appears as a grid: each comparable sale price divided by that property's gross rent at the time of sale. The appraiser picks a multiplier the comps support and applies it to the subject's rent. That result is the income indication of value.

How do you determine the sale price of a rental property?

Price it the way the appraiser will. Find recent sales of similar rentals, divide each sale price by its annual gross rent, and take the median of that cluster as the market multiplier. Multiply your own annual rent by it for a starting range, then adjust for anything the comps did not carry, such as higher taxes, owner-paid heat or deferred repairs.

What if the appraisal comes in lower than the purchase price?

Ask the lender for a reconsideration of value and support it with facts: a wrong unit count, a renovation the report missed, rent left off the rent roll, or better comparable sales with addresses, dates and rents. If the value holds, the choices are renegotiating the price, bringing more cash to keep the loan-to-value acceptable, or walking away.